Case(y) In Point

"Casey rocks. She's my best friend." Lucky commented as we were playing Guitar Hero.

"Casey Lynch?" Squeaker asked.

"This Casey." Lucky pointed to her favorite fictional character on Guitar Hero.

"That's Casey Lynch. (pause) I have a friend named Emily Lynch."

"You should ask her if she has a sister named Casey." Joked Lucky.

(pause)

"I did and she does! She has a younger sister named Casey."

(snort of laughter) That was me. I couldn't help it.

As Squeaker pointed out, Casey is a popular name right now so I guess it's possible.

I hear Wimblysnippet is gaining some popularity as well.